By Ken Spero
What happens to an aspiring principal’s development after they finish a preparation program but before they get a school?
A district may have invested months or years in developing that person. Then the coursework ends, the cohort stops meeting, and the candidate returns to a role that may offer few opportunities to practice the decisions they’ll face as a principal. Once they do get a school, those decisions come quickly.
The RAND evaluation commissioned by The Wallace Foundation found benefits in six districts that built comprehensive principal pipelines connecting leadership standards, preparation, hiring and placement, and support on the job. RAND studied the pipelines as a whole. For districts, that raises a practical question: How do we give leaders opportunities to keep developing their judgment as they move from one stage to the next?
That’s where I see a role for a Practice Infrastructure: a way to connect coursework, mentoring, field experience, and supervision through repeated opportunities to practice. A simulation gives leaders a realistic situation in which to decide what they would do, see what follows, and reflect on why they responded as they did. Districts can use that experience differently depending on where a leader is in the pipeline.
A 2026 study of eight large urban districts in Wallace’s Equity-Centered Pipeline Initiative adds another piece: who helps design the practice. Molle and colleagues found that district-university partnerships ranged from feedback on existing programs to joint design and delivery. Regular meetings helped sustain the work, and some partnerships supported sitting leaders as well as aspiring principals. The researchers also distinguished between working with community organizations and giving families and community members a voice in district decisions.
That suggests a practical starting point. A district and its university partner could choose a scenario together, ask families or community partners which perspectives it should reflect, and agree on what strong reasoning might look like. Candidates could work through it during preparation, then revisit a related challenge with a supervisor after placement. The study examined partnerships; this is one way districts could put its findings to work.
What two districts did with simulations
In an aspiring principals program in a large urban school district, candidates completed simulations and wrote about what they learned and how it applied to their work. Some replayed a scenario to see where a different decision would lead. The simulations also gave the cohort a common experience for monthly discussions about difficult issues, including equity-centered leadership. Candidates could compare what they noticed, whose perspectives they considered, and why they chose different responses.
A large countywide school district illustrates a different part of the value. Its team had been developing discussion questions and multiple-choice items for dozens of scenarios. Using an existing simulation library gave staff more flexibility to focus on the learning experience. In the district’s monthly leadership development sessions, aspiring leaders could step into an administrator’s role, work through situations such as a conflict within a teaching team, and discuss their decisions. Participants could also choose scenarios tied to their development needs and work through them with mentors and coaches.
Where districts can use the same investment
During preparation and while candidates await placement. Simulations give candidates a way to apply what they’re learning to situations that may never arise during their field experience. After the program ends, districts can continue assigning practice at a manageable pace. An AI Coach can guide reflection while the decisions and consequences are still fresh, even when a mentor isn’t available.
In assessment centers and credentialing. A district can ask candidates to explain what they noticed, what they prioritized, and why. Reporting aligned to selected Professional Standards for Educational Leaders (PSEL) can help trained reviewers locate and examine that work. If a district intends to use it in a formal readiness decision, it should establish clear scoring criteria and consider the work alongside other evidence. Leaders also need room to experiment in developmental practice without assuming every choice will count toward selection.
Between principal supervisor meetings. A principal can use a simulation to rehearse an upcoming challenge or revisit a topic from a previous meeting. A reflection grounded in their actual choices gives the next conversation a better starting point. The supervisor can spend more of that time helping the principal consider what applies in their school, rehearse a conversation, or decide what to do next.
With leadership teams and PLCs. Principals and aspiring leaders can facilitate simulations with their teams. The team gets to hear how colleagues interpret the same problem and where their priorities differ. The person leading the debrief gets practice asking questions, listening across perspectives, and helping the group decide what it wants to carry into its own work.
The value for districts and their leaders
The district business case starts with a practical question: What can we do with the time and resources we already have? An existing library can reduce the work of creating scenarios. Self-paced practice can extend access without requiring a facilitator for every session. Reflection between meetings can help supervisors use their time where their knowledge of the person and the school matters most. Those are ways to create capacity. Cash savings depend on whether expenses such as travel, release time, or purchased services actually change.
There’s a well-being dimension, too. A principal anticipating a difficult staff conversation may know it’s weighing on them without being able to say exactly why. Practice can help them name the concern, consider a few responses, and bring a more specific question to a supervisor or colleague. In a group debrief, hearing others wrestle with the same uncertainty can make it easier to ask for help. That’s one way a district can build support into the work of leadership development.
A district can start with one gap: give candidates who are waiting for placement a few well-chosen scenarios and a chance to discuss what they learned. Then ask where else that same practice would help. The value of a Practice Infrastructure is that the opportunity to keep developing judgment can follow leaders from preparation into the work itself.
Sources
RAND (2019). Principal Pipelines: A Feasible, Affordable, and Effective Way for Districts to Improve Schools. Commissioned by The Wallace Foundation.
SchoolSims client case studies (district names withheld).
Molle, D., Halverson, R., Probst, C., Liou, Y.-H., Mosby, J., Acosta, J., & Guan, X. (2026). The Role of Partnerships in Supporting Equity-Centered School Leadership. https://doi.org/10.59656/EL-LS5116.001
Interested in Learning More About SchoolSims?
Complete the form below for access to our Simulation Overviews, Pricing, or to Schedule a 15-minute Call to Walk through a Simulation.
SchoolSims provides dynamic, simulation-based professional development for educators and school leaders in public, private, and independent schools, as well as for future educators in colleges and universities. Our simulations present real-world leadership challenges through interactive, decision-based scenarios, leveraging AI-driven insights and live-action elements. By engaging in these experiences, learners refine their decision-making skills, bridge the gap between theory and practice, and enhance their ability to lead in complex educational environments.