By Ken Spero
The Myth of Certainty in Teaching
Every teacher knows the moment: you’ve planned carefully, differentiated thoughtfully, and then—something unexpected happens. A student challenges your grading policy. Technology fails in the middle of a lesson. The class dynamic shifts in a way you didn’t anticipate.
In those moments, teaching stops being about content and starts being about judgment. But here’s the paradox—while we tell teachers to “trust their judgment,” we rarely give them the space to practice difficult classroom decisions. Instead, we often reinforce the illusion that good teaching means being sure—about what to do, what to say, and how to react.
The truth is, classrooms live in the gray. And learning to thrive there—without losing confidence or wellness—is one of the most important professional skills that teacher training can develop.
The Pull of Certainty, the Cost of Avoidance
Human beings don’t like uncertainty. It triggers the same parts of the brain that respond to physical threat. So when teachers encounter complex situations—student behavior that doesn’t fit the script, parent expectations that conflict with policy, or ethical questions about AI and academic integrity—the instinct to find quick closure is powerful.
That’s uncertainty aversion: the impulse to end discomfort as fast as possible. It might look like sticking to a familiar routine instead of trying a riskier strategy, avoiding a difficult conversation with a student, or deflecting questions we don’t yet know how to answer. Research on cognitive load shows that constantly managing ambiguity without support drains mental resources.
When teachers are emotionally and cognitively overloaded, they become more reactive, less patient, and less creative. As a result, they may trade being reflective for exercising control. Their sense of efficacy—the belief that they can handle whatever arises—declines. And when teacher efficacy drops, student learning, relationships, and engagement follow. This cycle can diminish Wellness not because the work is too hard, but because teachers expect themselves to always have the answers.
AI, Ambiguity, and the Modern Classroom
The arrival of artificial intelligence in schools has made uncertainty unavoidable. Teachers are now navigating a landscape that changes daily. Should students use AI to brainstorm? To write? To study? How do we assess learning when the line between original and assisted work is blurred?
There’s no manual for this, only judgment—and that’s what makes it hard. Some teachers embrace AI in the classroom enthusiastically; others ban it entirely. Both reactions make sense, but they can also reflect an underlying need for clarity in an unclear moment.
The real challenge isn’t just about AI—it’s about how teachers build the emotional and cognitive flexibility to lead learning when the ground keeps shifting beneath them. What does effective teacher preparation look like in an ever-changing environment?
The Wellness Connection
When teachers internalize uncertainty as failure, stress compounds. The constant need to appear certain—to know, to control, to perform—takes a toll. It drains emotional reserves and can leave teachers feeling isolated or defeated. Over time, the aversion to uncertainty feeds burnout: the less comfortable we are with the unpredictable, the more exhausting the job becomes. We must be aware of this in order to take steps to prevent teacher burnout.
But wellness isn’t the absence of stress—it’s the ability to recover from it. And recovery requires reflection, community, and the understanding that uncertainty isn’t the enemy of professionalism; it’s part of it.
Simulations as Reflective Practice
That’s where simulation-centered learning changes the conversation. Sims invite teacher preparation through rich, realistic stories where there are no perfect answers—only thoughtful choices and real consequences.
In a SchoolSims simulation, a teacher might face a scenario about AI plagiarism, a parent confrontation, or a sudden ethical dilemma. Participants must decide, reflect, and see the outcomes unfold. They experience the tension of ambiguity—but within a psychologically safe environment. The process mirrors the cognitive and emotional demands of the classroom while reducing the risk.
Over time, teacher development leads to what psychologists call adaptive expertise—the ability to make sound, principled decisions under pressure, and to stay centered when circumstances are uncertain.
Learning to Teach in Uncertainty
Sims don’t train teachers to avoid mistakes—they help them learn from them. The power lies in reflection: talking through choices, understanding different perspectives, and exploring the ripple effects of action. That reflective space is where teacher confidence grows and wellness stabilizes.
Teaching will always involve the unpredictable: new technologies, new generations, new challenges. But practice can make the unpredictable less intimidating. By experiencing ambiguity through simulation, teachers build both their professional judgment and their emotional endurance.
Complete the form below to join our next webinar or receive the recording for the webinar related to this blog.